Escape, forget, recharge to this gorgeous ultra-private compound featuring historic main house and carriage house.

A spectacular pastoral setting, this historic compound features a country manor home and custom built guest house on 8 acres. The main residence has been beautifully restored with architectural details intact but with all the most up-to-date amenities. This gracious home has a relaxed country décor with a large living room with wood-burning fireplace and is flanked by a delightful sunroom overlooking a meadow. The library is flanked by another screened sunroom overlooking the lawn and garden. The formal dining room with French doors leads to a private stone terrace which is another outdoor dining space, perfect for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The generous eat-in kitchen is outfitted with top of-the-line appliances (Sub-Zero and Viking stove) and two dishwashers.  If you’d rather rest and relax and have someone else command the kitchen, might we recommend a visit from Kyle’s Catering. There are 3 bedrooms and 3.5 baths, including an en suite Master with attached private office. Each exquisite marble bath features a beautiful antique commode.

Staying at the Carriage House

The Carriage house is flooded with light and casual chic decor. There are 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and open living and dining space with French doors leading to a terrace overlooking the heated pool and views of the vast land reserve beyond. Ultra-private and serene, the park-like grounds are filled with native trees, plantings and flowering plants. Simply divine.

This property is offered with a choice of the Main House alone or the Main House + Carriage House. The house is available on a year-round basis or for the summer period; the minimum rental period is one month.

How to Reserve Shelter Island Vacation Rental

Shelter Island Heights Compound can be reserved through the owner’s representative.  Call Kimberly Feierstein at 516-972-3004 or email Kimberley at sihomerental@gmail.com.